Nobody has pulled this card yet. The first copy makes you its discoverer.
The American Horror Story cast changes each season but has included over 57 main actors across 13 seasons so far. Being an anthology series, many actors come and go across the seasons in both new and/or returning roles. Evan Peters and Sarah Paulson have appeared in the most seasons with 10 appearances each. This is closely followed by Lily Rabe and Frances Conroy who have both appeared in 9 seasons. Peters has portrayed the most characters across the show with 16, followed by Paulson who has portrayed 12. Naomi Grossman's character, Pepper, from Asylum was the first to reappear in a different season, Freak Show. Gabourey Sidibe's character, Queenie, who first appeared in Coven was the first character to appear in 4 or more seasons after reappearing in Hotel, Apocalypse, and 13. The series has cast many pop culture celebrities, TV personalities, singers, supermodels, or sports stars including Adam Levine, Stevie Nicks, Patti LaBelle, Lady Gaga, Naomi Campbell, Trixie Mattel, Rick Springfield, Gus Kenworthy, Eureka, Kaia Gerber, Kim Kardashian, and Alex Consani.